Published by Garden State Circle · Monmouth County

Restaurants · Monmouth County

American and New American Restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ

Every American and New American restaurant in the Monmouth County restaurant guides, with “Bar/BYOB”, “Cuisine”, “Cuisine type”, “Price tier”, “Reservations”, “Outdoor seating” and “Record checked” for each.

Garden State Circle title card: American and New American Restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ

The Guide: American and New American Restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ

See the Businesses

American and New American Restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ — Compared

This is not a ranking.

RestaurantBar/BYOBCuisineCuisine typePrice tierReservationsOutdoor seatingRecord checked
Upper Freehold Township (Cream Ridge), Millstone Township (Clarksburg, Perrineville), Allentown and Roosevelt
Happy Apple InnBarAmerican cuisineAmerican / New American$$YesYesOct 2026
The Roost RestaurantNot publishedAmericanAmerican / New American$Not publishedYesOct 2026
Asbury Park, Neptune Township (Ocean Grove, Shark River Hills), Neptune City and Ocean Township (Oakhurst, Wanamassa, Wayside)
Asbury Ale HouseBarAmerican classicsAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
BrickwallBarComfort tavern foodAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
SeaGrass RestaurantBYOBAmerican dishes with a twist, seafoodAmerican / New American, SeafoodNot publishedNoNot publishedOct 2026
Atlantic Highlands, Highlands and Keansburg
The Atlantic HouseBarPub-inspired; locally sourced and organic ingredientsAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
et al fine food & eventsNot publishedBistro; seasonal, handcrafted from scratchAmerican / New American$$YesYesOct 2026
Half MoonBarCoastal comfort cuisineAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Harborside GrillBarCasual dining; dishes from Penne Ala Vodka to a 16oz NY StripAmerican / New American$$Not publishedYesOct 2026
Mule Barn TavernBarAmerican; comfort foodAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Belmar, Avon-by-the-Sea, Bradley Beach, Spring Lake Heights and Lake Como
Cavé BistroNot publishedFarm-to-tableAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Marina GrilleBarCoastal-inspiredAmerican / New American, Seafood$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Spring Lake Tap HouseBarUpscale tavern cuisineAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Eatontown, Tinton Falls, West Long Branch and Shrewsbury Township
Apple Street KitchenBYOBCreative American cuisine, farm to tableAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
CJ McLoone’s Pub and GrilleBarAmerican tavern; casual American diningAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
The Pour HouseBarComfort foodAmerican / New American$$Not publishedYesOct 2026
The Squire Restaurant & BarBarSeafood, prime cuts, homemade pastaAmerican / New American$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Tally-Ho RestaurantBarAmerican cuisine with a strong Northern Italian influenceAmerican / New American, Italian$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Zachary’s RestaurantBarTraditional American fare; thin crust pizzaAmerican / New American, PizzaNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Freehold Borough, Freehold Township (West Freehold), Howell Township (Ramtown, Adelphia), Farmingdale, Manalapan Township and Englishtown
Metropolitan CafeBarNew AmericanAmerican / New American$$YesYesOct 2026
Olde Silver TavernBarRustic New American comfort foodAmerican / New American$$$YesYesOct 2026
The Standard (American Hotel)BarAmerican bistroAmerican / New American$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Matawan, Aberdeen Township (Cliffwood, Cliffwood Beach), Keyport, Hazlet Township and Union Beach
Brass Rail Bar & GrillBarPub fareAmerican / New American$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Court JesterNot publishedWings, burgers, comfort food, Southwestern-inspired optionsAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Maloney’s Pub & GrillBarPubAmerican / New American$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Yesterday’s RestaurantBarSouthern Italian and AmericanItalian, American / New American$$Not publishedYesOct 2026
Manasquan, Brielle, Sea Girt, Spring Lake and Wall Township (Allenwood, Glendola, West Belmar)
Brielle House Bar & GrillBarCoastal kitchen and barAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Coastal CanteenBarSeafood and coastal AmericanSeafood, American / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Harpoon Willy’sBarAmerican tavernAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Waypoint 622BarNew American, seafoodAmerican / New American, SeafoodNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Red Bank, Fair Haven, Rumson, Little Silver, Shrewsbury Borough, Monmouth Beach, Sea Bright and Middletown Township (Lincroft, Navesink, Locust)
Barrel & Roost (formerly Restaurant Nicholas)BarChef-driven comfort foodAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Beach TavernBarTraditional and adventurous menu (sushi, flatbread, sandwiches)American / New AmericanNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Charlie’s of LincroftBarContemporary AmericanAmerican / New American$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Felicia’s KitchenNot publishedAmericanAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Nauvoo Grill ClubBarModern AmericanAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Pearl at The Oyster Point HotelBarContemporary American with Asian and Southwest influencesAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Street Kitchen PubNot publishedClassic American fareAmerican / New American$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Victory Park TavernBarSeasonal AmericanAmerican / New AmericanNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026

About This Page

38 restaurants in this table. This page is a filtered view of restaurants already in our Monmouth County restaurant guides. A restaurant appears here when its cuisine, as recorded from its own website or posted menu, is American and New American as a primary or secondary cuisine. No restaurant is added here that is not in those guides. “Price tier” reads $ (most mains under $15), $$ ($15–$30), $$$ ($30–$50) or $$$$ (over $50 or a tasting menu); “Not published” means the restaurant has no readable posted menu. Restaurants are grouped by guide area, then listed alphabetically. This is not a ranking.

Source Guides

Something Out of Date?

This guide is maintained. If anything here is wrong or has changed — an address, a BYOB policy, whether a restaurant has closed — tell us and we will check it. Businesses listed here are welcome to write in directly.

[email protected]

Garden State Circle is supported by the businesses that participate in it. Participation pays for our ongoing work: keeping a business’s entry accurate, re-checking its record, and publishing a page of its own details that the business maintains. There is no paid placement in this guide. Participation does not buy a place here, a position here, or anything the comparison table says.