Published by Garden State Circle · Monmouth County

Restaurants · Monmouth County

Italian Restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ

Every Italian restaurant in the Monmouth County restaurant guides, with “Bar/BYOB”, “Cuisine”, “Cuisine type”, “Price tier”, “Reservations”, “Outdoor seating” and “Record checked” for each.

Garden State Circle title card: Italian Restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ

The Guide: Italian Restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ

See the Businesses

Italian Restaurants in Monmouth County, NJ — Compared

This is not a ranking.

RestaurantBar/BYOBCuisineCuisine typePrice tierReservationsOutdoor seatingRecord checked
Upper Freehold Township (Cream Ridge), Millstone Township (Clarksburg, Perrineville), Allentown and Roosevelt
Albivi Brick OvenNot publishedItalianItalian, PizzaNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
La Piazza RistoranteBarFamily Italian restaurant – Old Country SicilianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Ninuzzo TrattoriaBYOBTrattoria – pizza, pasta, pollo & vitello, del mareItalian, PizzaNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Vesuvio’s Pizza & Nick’s PlaceBarItalian family restaurant (Naples-style) with bar and Italian bistroItalian, PizzaNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Asbury Park, Neptune Township (Ocean Grove, Shark River Hills), Neptune City and Ocean Township (Oakhurst, Wanamassa, Wayside)
Belmonte’s RistoranteBYOBItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Brando’s Citi CucinaNot publishedSoulful Italian cuisineItalian$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
CapitolineBarCraft casual ItalianItalian$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Casa By The ShoreNot publishedKosher ItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Dolce FantasiaBYOBNorthern ItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Dominic’s Pizzeria & TrattoriaNot publishedItalianItalian, Pizza$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Flavia’s Cucina RomanaBYOBRoman ItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Il PostoBarItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Illiano’s Italian RestaurantBYOBItalianItalianNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Judy & Harry’sBarItalian classics with international flairItalian$$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
La Lupa di RomaNot publishedItalianItalian, PizzaNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Piccola ItaliaBarItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Posillipo Italian RestaurantNot publishedItalianItalian$$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Atlantic Highlands, Highlands and Keansburg
Christine’s Italian RistoranteBYOBItalian ristorante; prime beef, chicken and seafoodItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Fresh Restaurant & CateringNot publishedFarm-to-table; local farms and purveyorsItalian, Mediterranean / GreekNot publishedNot publishedYesOct 2026
Porcini RestaurantBYOBItalian; fresh pasta, seafood, Italian-American dishesItalian$$$YesYesOct 2026
Strada Pizza BarBarWood-fired pizze, antipasti and paste; ’little osteria’Pizza, ItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Belmar, Avon-by-the-Sea, Bradley Beach, Spring Lake Heights and Lake Como
Federici’s on 10thNot publishedItalian, brick-oven pizzaItalian, PizzaNot publishedNot publishedYesOct 2026
La Dolce VitaBarItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Marandola’sBYOBItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Vic’s Italian RestaurantBarItalianItalian, PizzaNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Eatontown, Tinton Falls, West Long Branch and Shrewsbury Township
Ember & EagleBarItalian-inspired steakhouseSteakhouse, Italian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Illiano’s CafeBYOB – wine and spiritsPasta, veal and seafood entréesItalian$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Maurizio’s Pizza & RistoranteBYOBTraditional Italian dishes with a modern American touchItalian, PizzaNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Nettie’sBarItalian AmericanItalian$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Tally-Ho RestaurantBarAmerican cuisine with a strong Northern Italian influenceAmerican / New American, Italian$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Freehold Borough, Freehold Township (West Freehold), Howell Township (Ramtown, Adelphia), Farmingdale, Manalapan Township and Englishtown
Clarizio’s Italian RistoranteBYOBItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Federici’s Family Italian RestaurantNot publishedItalianItalianNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
La CipollinaNot publishedItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
La LupaBYOBUna piccola trattoriaItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Mezza LunaNot publishedItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Nonna’s Citi CucinaBarItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Solo TrattoriaBYOBItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Vincent’s Italian RestaurantNot publishedItalianItalian$$YesYesOct 2026
Colts Neck Township, Holmdel Township and Marlboro Township (Morganville)
Amorina Ristorante ItalianoBYOBItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Osteria Cucina RusticaBarContemporary ItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Patricia’s of HolmdelBYOBItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Sam VeraBarItalianItalian$$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Via Sposito (Colts Neck)BarItalianItalianNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Matawan, Aberdeen Township (Cliffwood, Cliffwood Beach), Keyport, Hazlet Township and Union Beach
A Salute Italian Restaurant & BarBarItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Assaggini Di RomaBYOBItalianItalianNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Il LeoneBYOBFarm to table ItalianItalianNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Limoncello at Piazza di RomaBarItalianItalian$$YesYesOct 2026
Pauline’s Italian CuisineNot publishedItalian; meats, seafoods, pastasItalianNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Yesterday’s RestaurantBarSouthern Italian and AmericanItalian, American / New American$$Not publishedYesOct 2026
Long Branch, Interlaken, Oceanport, Deal (Elberon), Allenhurst and Loch Arbour
Johnny Piancone’sBarItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Sirena RistoranteBarClassic ItalianItalianNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Manasquan, Brielle, Sea Girt, Spring Lake and Wall Township (Allenwood, Glendola, West Belmar)
Antonio’s Trattoria Cucina ItalianaNot publishedItalianItalian$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Due AmiciBarItalianItalianNot publishedNot publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Lubrano’s TrattoriaBYOBItalianItalian$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Rella’s Italian Tavern & CafeBarItalian tavernItalian$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Squan TavernBarPizza and sandwichesPizza, Italian$$Not publishedNot publishedOct 2026
Via Veneto RistoranteNot publishedItalianItalianNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Red Bank, Fair Haven, Rumson, Little Silver, Shrewsbury Borough, Monmouth Beach, Sea Bright and Middletown Township (Lincroft, Navesink, Locust)
Anjelica’s RestaurantNot publishedItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Buona SeraBarItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Gabriella’s Italian SteakhouseBarItalian steakhouseItalian, SteakhouseNot publishedYesYesOct 2026
Little BucaBYOBItalian, SicilianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
LocaleBarItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Monticello at Red BankBarItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
Olivia’s Trattoria & Artisan PizzaNot publishedItalian, artisan pizzaItalian, PizzaNot publishedNot publishedYesOct 2026
PazzoBarItalianItalianNot publishedYesNot publishedOct 2026
SemolinaBYOBFarm-to-table, fresh pastasItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
UndiciBarItalianItalian$$$YesNot publishedOct 2026
Via SpositoNot publishedItalianItalian, Pizza$$YesNot publishedOct 2026

About This Page

68 restaurants in this table. This page is a filtered view of restaurants already in our Monmouth County restaurant guides. A restaurant appears here when its cuisine, as recorded from its own website or posted menu, is Italian as a primary or secondary cuisine. No restaurant is added here that is not in those guides. “Price tier” reads $ (most mains under $15), $$ ($15–$30), $$$ ($30–$50) or $$$$ (over $50 or a tasting menu); “Not published” means the restaurant has no readable posted menu. Restaurants are grouped by guide area, then listed alphabetically. This is not a ranking.

Source Guides

Something Out of Date?

This guide is maintained. If anything here is wrong or has changed — an address, a BYOB policy, whether a restaurant has closed — tell us and we will check it. Businesses listed here are welcome to write in directly.

[email protected]

Garden State Circle is supported by the businesses that participate in it. Participation pays for our ongoing work: keeping a business’s entry accurate, re-checking its record, and publishing a page of its own details that the business maintains. There is no paid placement in this guide. Participation does not buy a place here, a position here, or anything the comparison table says.